I’m not actually sure who they are but my guesses are the top one is Yvonne DeCarlo and the bottom one is Clara Bow.
MATTHEW'S ISLAND
I’m not actually sure who they are but my guesses are the top one is Yvonne DeCarlo and the bottom one is Clara Bow.
MATTHEW'S ISLAND 
Pumpkin witch is Clara Bow, you’re right. Don’t know the other, but I don’t think it is Yvonne.
I’m going to keep trying to place that mystery face until I (or you) figure it out. Any other guesses? Paulette?
I take that back. It’s not Paulette.
Possibly Linda Darnell? This is a tough one!
I’ve found another photo of Clara Bow with the same very distinctive pumpkin. My best guess on the other witch is that she is Peter Lorre in drag.
Peter Lorre in drag is a good guess. Linda Darnell is an even better guess. I think you may be right on that one.
The first is 40’s actress Lucia Carroll:
https://www.listal.com/lucia-carroll/pictures
Peter Lorre? You’re a bad boy… :))